"We view ethnic identity as reflected in a constellation of social categorizations in which the self is located" (p. They present the case as though the Ninni family as a whole shares a social identity without examining the unique identities of women and men.Ĭameron and Lalonde (1994) agree that self-identity is multi-dimensional and context specific. The identity of "Italian family" may give meaning to social identities of "family" and "Italian," as well as "immigrant." Eyles and Perri also did not compare the meanings of family and ethnicity for women and men. 117).Įyles and Perri's conclusion opposes "family" and "ethnicity" as though they are separate identities, when, in fact, ethnic identity is multi-dimensional. These authors argue that into the third generation, "in many ways, 'family' has replaced ethnicity as the central focus of Ninni life" (p. They also celebrated fortunate life events together. Also family members supported one another through difficult circumstances such as bankruptcy and financial problems. Rituals such as Sunday dinner sustained the close family bonds. For example, Eyles and Perri's (1993) life history study of three generations of the Ninni family found that the family was a close-knit group. Most of the literature reviewed sees family as central to Italian immigrant identity, and my findings agree. In this paper I argue that gender identity is a facet of ethnic identity that must be distinguished in order to understand the preservation and transformation of Italian culture in Canada. However, even in this study of men, the gender dimension is ignored as conclusions are assumed to pertain to all Italians. An exception is a survey study of male Italian immigrants in Calgary (Aliaga 1994). Therefore, there has been less written about identity formation specifically among Italian immigrant women or men. This may be because the largest body of literature is concerned to explain how immigrant culture is changing, and what factors will lead to its perpetuation or diminution in future generations. Reviewing the literature, it is striking that some studies of Italian ethnic identity do not consider Italian women in their own right. All of the respondents settled in Toronto for their adult lives. The oldest member of the study came to Canada in 1928, whereas all the others immigrated between 19. In another three cases, the women's husbands participated in the interview. ![]() All of them had married and now had adult children, and in some cases, grandchildren. The respondents ranged in age from 88 to 54 years. My research is based on qualitative analysis of interviews with seven first-generation Italian immigrant women and one French-Canadian woman who married a first-generation Italian immigrant in northern Quebec. When we listen to Italian women speaking in their own words, and take into account the context of their lives, we can have a fuller understanding of who they are. ![]() My research question is the following: how do first generation Italian women immigrants define their identities in their accounts of their lives, and in statements of their values? My question is important so we can broaden our understanding of older Italian women beyond popular stereotypes. I am interested in identifying patterns in the way women present themselves as individuals, as women, as family members, as Italians, as immigrants, as workers, and in other ways. I will present data from interviews with immigrant families, which are archived in the "Lives and Legacies" database. In this paper I will examine the self-identity of first generation Italian women immigrants in Toronto. reflection on your contribution to the existing literatureĮarly Rough Draft of a Research Paper First Generation Italian Women Immigrants in Toronto. ![]() reflection on how well you have been able to answer your research question with the data you have.reflection on how your analysis emerged, perhaps including your preconceptions and how these changed.evidence from the data to support your analysis.an organized presentation of your analysis according to themes or concepts.These ideas will be further refined and organized as you write the draft. ![]() In the draft you will bring together and attempt to synthesise the ideas you developed through the steps of reading, coding and memoing. In drafting a qualitative research paper, the objective is to have an intitial go at presenting the analysis, while at the same time continuing to do the analysis. Analysis » Drafting the Research Paper Objectives of Writing a Draft
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |